101°F
weather icon Clear

Black or white? Can HOA determine fence color?

Q: We recently purchased a home in a relatively new community. It has several retention ponds and several areas of preserve land. The combination provides nice scenic views for many of the homes. The home is on corner lot with a view of a pond and preserve. When we first visited the community, we saw that several homes had black picket fences along the back and sides of their yards, which makes for great views of the surrounding areas.

The homeowners association has restrictive rules regarding the type of fence that can be installed. The rules state only homes that are “abutting” water can have black picket fences along the rear of the property, and all other fencing must be white or tan 6-feet-high vinyl fence.

Once in the home, we read through some material the previous owner left for us. We discovered she had installed 3-foot-to-6-foot wide sections of the black picket fence along a small area on the side of the yard. The HOA made her remove the fence since it didn’t comply with the rules.

Discovering this situation, we communicated with the HOA (actually the management company) asking why the fence wasn’t allowed when there were several homes that had the black picket fence that did abut water and the fence was on all sides of the property. They indicate a few homes had gotten a “variance” from the builder to have the fences. They also stated one home got approval, no explanation why, for the black fence when the property did not conform to the fence rule.

If the HOA allows exceptions like those stated, how can they then enforce the rule for other homes like ours? Do we have recourse to obtain approval to install the black fence?

A: It is not unusual for a developer to grant a variance during the time period that it has control over the association’s operations. I have seen this occurrence a number of times. Once a variance has been given to a homeowner, it would be extremely difficult and costly to have a homeowner-controlled board to have that homeowner resubmit an architectural request that follows the guidelines of the association. In this case, for the homeowners to remove their black fences.

The fact that the developer and or previous boards granted the variances does not necessarily negate the current and future boards from properly enforcing the association’s governing documents.

Q: A woman ran for our board of directors without disclosing that she was suing our community, which was against the Nevada Revised Statutes codes. A number of us followed the necessary steps outlined by the ombudsman to protest.

For about 18 months I have written to the ombudsman about this issue, including all the paperwork. He never acknowledges (it). I have even written to the attorney general for help getting the ombudsman to do his job. Do you have any advice for me?

A: Between the pandemic, closed offices and more complaints than investigators, it would not surprise me that you have not heard back from the Ombudsman’s Office. My recommendation is to contact the new ombudsman as Charvez Foger no longer holds that position. The email address is cicombudsman@red.nv.gov. You also may want to contact the Commission for Common-Interest Communities and Condominium Hotels supervisor at 702-486-4480 and ask for an appointment with the ombudsman or the investigator that has your complaint.

As to the homeowner who did not disclose the lawsuit, I don’t believe that you will receive much satisfaction from the division. NRS 116 laws do not clearly provide any penalties per se for those homeowners who do not provide full disclosure.

Barbara Holland is an author and educator on real estate management. Questions may be sent to holland744o@gmail.com.

THE LATEST
HOA vice president has right to hear complaint against him

If the president wants to review the complaint with the full board, the president should call for a formal hearing. The president should not be judge and jury.

Homeowner says letter wasn’t nice but it wasn’t harassment

I sent management a couple of emails they didn’t like. Now I’m being charged for harassment. There is no bylaw covering “you have to be nice to management,” so they are citing me under a “no firearms are to be discharged/ no unsafe fires are to be started.”

Homeowners association has power to fine fighters

I live in a townhouse community. There is a home where the residents nearly daily get into extremely loud, screaming fights. Police have been called more than a few times. Numerous complaints have been filed to the homeowners association, but nothing seems to be getting done.

What new water restrictions could communities face?

It does not take a rocket scientist to know that we have a major water issue in Southern Nevada. Lake Mead is now 29 percent full. I can remember going to Lake Mead with my family to see the water that was overflowing in the 1990s through the spillways. The writing is on the wall!

New water law unclear when it comes to communities

You are not the only one waiting for clarification. I think we all are waiting for direction. It is my understanding the law, which was passed last legislative session, excluded residential owners who own their own property. This would include their front and backyards. Common areas of an association would fall under the new law as to whether your common area landscape is inefficient use of grass.

Homeowner wants rental cap for new community

Based on the six-month rental clause in your governing documents, there is no rental cap. You could have a significant number of renters. You would have to talk with the developer and see if they are willing to modify the CCRs to have a rental cap not to exceed 25 percent of the units.

Homeowner has long list of HOA complaints

As to the first item: Set an appointment with the management company and bring all of your documentation. It may take then a week or so for their accounting department to go through their records. Assuming that the same management company has been in place during the last six years, the accounting department should be able to view your information against the association records.

Large tree sheds leaves into neighbor’s yard, pool

If you have not contacted the owner of the house, please do so. If you don’t feel comfortable meeting face to face, then send the homeowner a letter. You may want to include some photographs. Ask the owner to please take care of overhangs, otherwise you will be forced to have your landscaper cut the limbs. By placing your neighbor on notice, allowing a reasonable amount of time for the neighbor to respond, you would be reducing any liability from the neighbor by trimming the tree.