Betting snafu robs Breeders’ Cup of some of its thunder
Last weekend’s Breeders’ Cup at Del Mar lived up to its promise, delivering sensational international racing at an amazing venue.
Unfortunately, the single serious snafu — a strange starting gate incident that led to the removal of an entrant from the betting pools in one of the Breeders’ Cup races — was the hottest conversation topic when it was over.
As recounted here, the 14 horses in Friday’s nightcap, the $1 million Juvenile Turf, had been loaded in the gate and were awaiting the start when a ruckus erupted in the inside stalls. No. 2, Albahr, flipped in the gate and was scratched. So, too, was No. 1 Modern Games, at least briefly.
It was quickly discovered that the horse had been wrongfully removed due to a series of miscommunications, so the stewards allowed the Godolphin-owned son of Dubawi to race, albeit for purse money only.
If you don’t already know, Modern Games won nicely in the one-mile race, finishing 1½ lengths clear of Tiz The Bomb, while the latter was the winner as far as the parimutuel pools were concerned.
The connections were delighted to collect the $520,000 winner’s share of the purse, I’m sure, as were those lucky folks who wagered on Tiz The Bomb to win. But countless bettors around the world who backed Modern Games were given the royal shaft.
Those who bet Modern Games to win, place or show got their money back at least, though they had to endure watching their horse cross the finish line in front. But those who used the horse in multi-race wagers were doubly burned, as their bets were transferred to the post time favorite, Dakota Gold. He finished fifth, as if it mattered.
If anything good comes from this colossal failure, it should be a universal rule allowing bettors to designate alternate selections in exotic wagers if one of their horses is scratched. It’s really not rocket science, as the technology was available back when I was filling out paper Pick 6 tickets at Bay Meadows in the 1980s.
A few other quick Breeders’ Cup observations:
— Bob Baffert now has the early betting favorite for the Kentucky Derby after Corniche’s impressive win in the Breeders’ Cup Juvenile. That creates an interesting situation given the trainer is banned from entering horses at Churchill Downs for two years following this year’s Derby debacle and thus Corniche received no Kentucky Derby points for his victory.
— The Del Mar tracks were fairer than in 2017. Speed was dangerous on both courses, but several horses came from the clouds to win as well, particularly on the turf course.
— Post-race drug tests of the top four finishers in each race and other random runners all came up clean, the California Horse Racing Board announced Thursday.
— All horses and riders came back safe as well, as Albahr suffered only a few minor cuts and scrapes during the scary starting gate incident. Carl Woods, the assistant starter who was injured during the incident, has informed the CHRB that he is fine and has returned to work.
‘Find an Irishman’
I discovered a new handicapping angle at a post-race celebration at the Pennant bar in Mission Bay, where I encountered a gaggle of wildly celebrating 30-somethings who, it soon became clear, had made a big score at the Breeders’ Cup that day.
It turns out, several of them had bet the exacta on the top two finishers in the Distaff — Japan-based Marche Lorraine, the winner at odds of 49-1, and runner-up Dunbar Road, herself a 12-1 shot. The return was $513.30 for each dollar wagered, and they, I was told, had it multiple times.
When I asked one of the celebrants how they’d managed to come up with those horses, he replied that he’d never been to a horse race until that day, so had asked a friend with a little knowledge of the game how to decide which horses to bet on. His friend responded that the best technique he knew was to “Find an Irishman and see who he likes.”
A short time later, near the crowded Del Mar paddock, the neophyte heard someone saying “Excuse me, excuse me” with a noticeable Irish accent and buttonholed the gent to find out who he liked. The Irishman replied that he was all over the 10 and 11, numbers that turned out to correspond with the winner and runner-up.
So there you have it. The next time my handicapping heads south, I might just have to give it a try.
Mike Brunker’s horse racing column appears Fridays. He can be reached at mbrunker@reviewjournal.com or 702-383-4656. Follow @mike_brunker on Twitter.
Ellis Starr's Bessarabian Stakes analysis
Even with so many of the eight entrants proven in stakes or entering the race off top efforts, Aug Lutes and Gidgetta appear to have a significant edge over the rest based on their most recent efforts.
Aug Lutes gets slight preference of the pair, not only because she has won four of five career races and finished second in the other, but because she's on a pattern for significant improvement off a career-best 102 Equibase Speed Figure earned last month posting the 19 to 1 upset in the Glen Cove Stakes at Belmont. That race, her first ever on turf, was run at the same 7-furlong distance of the Bessarabian, and right before that Aug Lutes rallied from 10th to second in the Duchess Stakes at this 7-furlong trip on the Tapeta main track at Woodbine. Jockey Antonio Gallardo, who is one of the top jockeys at Woodbine, rode Aug Lutes to that win at Presque Isle Downs in September, which followed a 10 month layoff, then rode her again in the Duchess. Likely to take another step forward as a lightly raced 3-year-old, off the pattern of figures from 88 to 95 to 102, and proven to love the all-weather main track surface, Aug Lutes may be very tough to beat in this race.
That being said, Gidgetta may give Aug Lutes all she can handle if she takes to the surface as it appears she might based on her two recent workouts after shipping in from California. Never worse than third in five sprint races this year on turf, Gidgetta earned a career-best 108 figure when finishing second in May, then two races later in a sprint earned a 105 figure before a 104 figure effort winning by a nose last month. Owned and bred by famous sports radio host Jim Rome (Jungle Racing), Gidgetta is showing every sign of running as well on the Tapeta all-weather surface as she did on turf. In her first local workout on Oct. 30, Gidgetta worked :47.8 for a half-mile which was the 13th best of 90 workouts at the distance on the day. Then, in her most recent workout on Nov. 8, the filly worked the same half-mile in a scintillating :47 flat which was the best workout of the day for the distance. With Patrick Husbands getting on for top trainer Josie Carroll and with it likely Gidgetta is going to run another "A" race like her last four sprints, the stretch run of this race between her and Aug Lutes promises to be very exciting.
Our Secret Agent has to be considered a contender to win as well. Her consistent career record of 3-6-3 in 12 career sprint races tells us she shows up with a competitive effort every time. As part of that record, Our Secret Agent finished third in the 2020 Bessarabian as well as second in the 2020 Duchess Stakes (with a career-best 100 figure), the same race Aug Lutes finished second in this year. Our Secret Agent also just won the Hendrie Stakes at the slightly shorter distance of 6 1/2 furlongs last month. The addition of blinkers for that race appears to have made a big difference, as did the jockey change to Kazushi Kimura, who had not ridden the filly since July of 2020, also to victory. With her last two sprint efforts yielding 98 and 99 figures not too far from the best efforts of Gidgetta and Aug Lutes, Our Secret Agent may have what it takes to win this race and even if she doesn't win she is highly probable to finish second or third as she's done so many times previously.
The rest of the field, with their best Equibase Speed Figures: Emmeline (101); Juxtapose (100); La Libertee (91); Lady Speightspeare (98); Spun Glass (96); and Tuned (104).
Ellis Starr is the national racing analyst for Equibase. Visit the Equibase website for more on the race or to purchase handicapping products.
